Custom Cooperstown Baseball Trading Pins
Start Your Custom Cooperstown Pin Design Today!
Custom Cooperstown pins are a great way to make your team stand out and give players something exciting to trade, collect and remember. Personalize your baseball trading pins with team logos, mascots, colors, player numbers and eye-catching details to create a design that looks cool and captures your team’s personality.
Whether you need pins for your first Cooperstown tournament or want to top last season’s design, we can help create something your players will be proud to trade. Request a free design to see how your custom Cooperstown baseball pins could look before placing your order.
Top Tier Designs for Top Tier Teams
Make All-Star Memories to Last a Lifetime
Choosing the Right Finish for Your Cooperstown Pins
Soft enamel is the go-to choice for Cooperstown trading pins. Its raised metal lines and recessed colors give every detail a bold, textured look that stands out when players trade. It also offers plenty of room for team colors, mascots, and creative designs.
View Custom Cooperstown Pins We Have Created
Make your Cooperstown pins stand out with details players will love. Add spinners, glitter, dangles, or custom backstamps to showcase your team’s name, tournament year, and personality. These finishing touches turn each pin into a keepsake players can trade and treasure long after the tournament.
Add-Ons and Specialty Cooperstown Pins
Add-Ons for Your Cooperstown Pins
-
Glitter Enamel – Add sparkle and shine to your pins with glitter-filled colors
-
Glow in the Dark – Make parts of your pin glow for a late night surprise!
-
Danglers – Add years/logos as a dangler and draw extra attention
-
Custom Backstamps – Include your team roster or a slogan on the back in raised metal.
-
Spinners or Sliders – Add movement and dimension for a more dynamic, eye-catching design.
Same Mold, Endless Options
Get more from one Cooperstown pin design by using the same mold to create multiple variations. Change the team colors or metal plating, or add glow-in-the-dark enamel or glitter for a fresh look!
Since the shape and raised details stay the same, you can offer players a coordinated set of pins with a different version to discover and trade, as well as getting a break on pricing!
Request a Design
Bring your team’s Cooperstown pin to life with a custom design made for trading. Share your logo, mascot, team colors, and tournament year, and our design team will create a free digital proof so you can see your pin before production.